My recommendation is buy a new lighted 6 or 8 switch panel.
Done. You know, I was just going to do toggle switches until I read this...then it dawned on me how much sense it made! I'll know at a glance if a device is getting power, or not.
You didn't mention Fuel Gauge. They usually came with a momentary switch but an on/off is better for when you're by yourself...
Yup! I have fuel, tach, water pressure, voltage and trim (I think I can do without trim). And I didn't even consider including them in my wiring schematic....told ya I was green!
SO...
The new question is "How is 12V power fed TO your switches?"
Do you have separate 12V feeds from battery, thru an inline fuse, to each switch or is there a fuse block fed by a heavy (8 gauge) wire from the battery?
Is the main feed fused at the battery?
I have two batteries with a battery switch....please see the pics below of the cluster I'm facing.
Disclaimer: When I looked at this crap, I felt overwhelmed. Instead of trying to jump in and immediately figure it out, I instead took pictures to analyze at home with a clear head. I'm feeling good again.
Connectors at the pos and neg with missing wires,
more positive wires than there are negative wires!!!. That cream colored wire at the pos is going into the cabin....could be the lights...could be the stereo. Obviously, removal of the empty connectors, tracing all those positive wires and figuring out where the negatives are going is in order.
That little harness....

That large black cable is the steering cable. I believe my first and easiest traces will be to identify all the thick black cables, as they SHOULD be steering, throttle and trim tab controls.
That thick white cable is coming from the cabin and running ALLLLL the way to the battery...nice...real nice.
The creme de la creme. And I have yet to find any busses near the battery.
Any input, comments, questions or jokes are welcomed!